50:50 Directors/Shareholders 2个股东/董事

案情：

1. P和D是A公司的唯一董事和股东。
2. 由于D，D的母亲和D的丈夫对A提起的法律诉讼，P和D之间的关系已经破裂。
3. A参与了几个正在进行的开发项目，A需要向这些项目的承包商，分包商和供应商付款。
4. D指示分包商停止这些项目的工作。
5. 所有A的支票都必须由D或她的丈夫签署。 D或她的丈夫坚持拒绝共同签署支票。
6. P要求公司召开董事会会议或会员会议或特别大会（’EGM’），但D一直拒绝参加会议。
7. P要求法院命令开会董事会会议，会员会议和特别大会。

 

法庭判决：

1. D拒绝或试图推迟或阻挠P所召集的任何会议。
2. 如果D是真诚的并且热衷于A的利益，她没有理由不去参加或找借口避免这些会议。
3. P和D是A的唯一董事和股东。A的公司章程有注明一定要两个人出席才能让会议合法进行。
4. 在这种僵局，指定进行会议是合适的，这样才能让A可以继续运作。
5. 法院下令召集，召开和进行会议。无论在会议上提出和考虑的，会员必须考虑和解决。

 

Facts:

1. P and D were the only directors and shareholders of A company.
2. The relationship between P and D had broken down due to legal suits filed by D, D’s mother in law and D’s husband against A.
3. A engaged in several ongoing development projects which they need to pay contractors, subcontractors and suppliers in those projects.
4. D instructed the subcontractors to stop work in those projects.
5. All cheques of A had to be signed by D or her husband. D or her husband persistently refused to co-sign the cheques.
6. P had been calling for board of directors meeting or members meeting or extra-extraordinary general meeting (‘EGM’) of the companies but D had persistently refused to attend the meetings.
7. P prayed the court order a meeting to be called.

 

Court held:

1. D had refused or attempted to delay or frustrate any of the meetings called by P.
2. If D was sincere and keen in the interests of A, there was no reason for her not to attend or to give excuses to avoid those meetings.
3. P and D were the only directors and shareholders of A and the coram of two was as required by the article of association of the A to convene or conduct a meeting of A.
4. With this deadlock, it was appropriate to order a meeting so that A which was ongoing could continue with their operations.
5. The court ordered a meeting to be called, held and convened; whatever to be tabled and considered in the meeting is for the meeting of the members to consider and resolve.

 

[2015] 8 MLJ 569 High Court

---

*Please contact us for appointment and/or business enquiries.

*Please visit our legal firm’s website: www.kuekong.com

*Please visit our FB law Group: http://bit.ly/fblawnjustice

*Like our FB Page: http://bit.ly/lawnjusticefbpage

*Please subscribe our YouTube: http://bit.ly/lawnjustice

*Please visit our web forum: http://www.queco.org

*Kuek Ong & Associates